Judge Montoya rules in favor of Doctor Brad Penenberg in malpractice case

The Medical Board of California Panel B convened on May 14, 2025, to discuss various matters, including a significant case involving Dr. Brad Pinenberg, a highly regarded orthopedic surgeon. The meeting highlighted Dr. Pinenberg's extensive qualifications and experience, noting his 35 years in practice, numerous patents, and publications in peer-reviewed journals.

The primary focus of the discussion was a complaint against Dr. Pinenberg regarding his preoperative care of a patient who underwent knee replacement surgery in 2017. The complainant alleged that Dr. Pinenberg failed to adequately assess the patient prior to the procedure. However, it was emphasized that the evidence overwhelmingly supported Dr. Pinenberg's actions, as reflected in Judge Montoya's decision, which found no unprofessional conduct.

The patient in question had a complex medical history, including chronic renal failure and a previous unsuccessful knee replacement. He was under the care of nephrologist Dr. Brahmani, who had referred him to Dr. Pinenberg for the surgery. The discussions underscored that the patient's referral was appropriate given his medical condition and the ongoing pain he experienced from the failed surgery.

Overall, the meeting reinforced Dr. Pinenberg's reputation as a leading orthopedic surgeon and clarified the circumstances surrounding the complaint, concluding that the care provided was appropriate and in line with medical standards. Further actions or follow-ups regarding this case were not detailed in the meeting.