Local leaders criticize Scott Dam removal for threatening water supply and wildlife

During a recent Town Hall meeting in Lake County, concerns were raised about the potential removal of Scott Dam and its implications for the local community and environment. Residents expressed fears that decommissioning the dam could severely impact both the people and wildlife in the Eel and Russian River watersheds.

Speakers highlighted that the removal of Scott Dam would eliminate a crucial year-round water source, which could lead to detrimental effects on various species. They estimated that the true cost of decommissioning the dam could reach as high as $2 billion, far exceeding the initial $500 million estimate. This figure includes costs for new water infrastructure, restoration projects, and long-term monitoring, which have not been fully accounted for in current discussions.

The meeting also addressed the interconnectedness of water systems in the region, noting that proposed improvements and new infrastructure projects are primarily located outside Lake County, raising concerns about local representation and interests. Residents emphasized the need for a comprehensive evaluation of the impacts of dam removal on the Lake Pillsbury area, including potential benefits from modernizing the dam for seismic safety and fish passage.

Community members called for a full regional cost-benefit analysis to ensure that the financial burdens of dam removal do not fall disproportionately on local taxpayers and ratepayers. They urged for more thorough studies to be conducted, as previous assessments had indicated a need for additional information.

As discussions continue, the community remains focused on ensuring that their voices are heard in decisions that could significantly affect their water supply and environmental health. The meeting underscored the importance of balancing ecological restoration efforts with the needs and concerns of local residents.