City attorney files nonrenewal complaint against Red Rooster bar following fatal incident

The Alcohol License Review Committee (ALRC) of Madison, Wisconsin, convened on May 29, 2025, for a special separations meeting to address a formal complaint regarding the non-renewal of a liquor license for the Red Rooster establishment. This meeting marked a significant procedural shift from previous discussions, as it involved a formal complaint initiated by the city attorney's office under Madison General Ordinance 38.1.

The meeting began with Attorney McReynolds outlining the nature of the complaint, emphasizing that this process differs from earlier discussions that focused on conditions for license renewal. Instead, the current situation involves a summons and complaint, which requires the licensee to respond to the allegations presented. Attorney McReynolds clarified that the meeting served as an initial appearance, akin to a court hearing, where the licensee could admit or deny the facts alleged in the complaint.

Committee members engaged in a brief discussion about the procedural aspects of the meeting. Attorney Zillavy, representing the city attorney's office, presented the complaint, detailing a tragic incident from December 2024 that resulted in a fatal car accident linked to the Red Rooster. Zillavy expressed concern over the establishment's management, citing multiple violations, including the presence of unlicensed bartenders and overserving patrons. The complaint was prompted by the serious nature of the incident, which involved patrons consuming alcohol after bar hours, leading to a charge of homicide against the bar manager.

As the meeting progressed, the committee members considered the implications of the complaint and the potential consequences for the Red Rooster. The licensee, Mr. Payne, was present and acknowledged receipt of the complaint but sought clarification on whether legal representation was necessary for the proceedings.

The ALRC did not hear evidence or testimony during this meeting, as it was primarily focused on procedural matters. The committee will schedule a future hearing to address the evidence and testimonies related to the complaint.

In conclusion, the ALRC's meeting highlighted serious concerns regarding the management of the Red Rooster and set the stage for further proceedings that could impact the establishment's ability to operate in the future. The committee's next steps will involve a detailed examination of the allegations and the circumstances surrounding the complaint.