Health Expert challenges water fluoridation at New York City Council meeting

During the Battle Ground City Council meeting on June 2, 2025, a significant discussion emerged regarding the controversial topic of water fluoridation. A speaker, who identified as a former proponent of fluoridation, expressed strong opposition to the practice, citing recent data and studies that question its effectiveness and safety.

The speaker presented a graph from the World Health Organization, illustrating that over the past two decades, the gap in dental health outcomes between fluoridated and non-fluoridated countries has narrowed significantly. This trend raises concerns about the purported benefits of fluoridation, which the speaker argued have diminished over time. Citing a Cochrane review, recognized for its rigorous evaluation of health studies, the speaker noted that there appears to be little to no benefit from fluoridation since around 2005.

Additionally, the speaker referenced data from New York counties, suggesting that increased fluoridation rates did not correlate with decreased dental decay as expected. This assertion challenges the foundational rationale behind water fluoridation, which is aimed at reducing cavities.

The discussion also touched on potential health risks associated with fluoride consumption. The speaker highlighted warnings from the FDA regarding fluoride in toothpaste, emphasizing that even small amounts should not be swallowed. Furthermore, the speaker raised concerns about the lack of safety studies from major health organizations, including the EPA and CDC, regarding the long-term effects of fluoride exposure.

The speaker concluded with a poignant note on the potential risks to vulnerable populations, particularly infants, citing increases in premature births and miscarriages. This call to action underscored the need for further examination of fluoridation practices and their implications for public health.

As the meeting progressed, other community members, including Jessica Cole, were set to address the council, indicating that the topic of water fluoridation may continue to be a focal point for future discussions. The council's response to these concerns and the potential for policy changes regarding water fluoridation will be closely watched by residents and health advocates alike.