This article was created by AI using a video recording of the meeting. It summarizes the key points discussed, but for full details and context, please refer to the video of the full meeting.
Link to Full Meeting
San Antonio's Board of Adjustment convened on June 2, 2025, to discuss a significant request from the law office of David E. Dilley, seeking multiple variances for a property located at the intersection of West Craig Place and Howard Street in the Monte Vista Historical Neighborhood Association. The applicant is requesting a special exception to allow an 8-foot predominantly open fence in the front yard, a 15-foot 6-inch variance from the minimum 25-foot corner clear vision requirement, and a 7-foot variance from the minimum 15-foot driveway clear vision.
The proposed fence height exceeds the maximum allowed height of 5 feet, which has raised concerns among city staff and local residents. Staff recommended denial of the requests, citing that the alterations would significantly change the character of the historic district, as no other properties in the immediate area feature similar fencing. Additionally, the requested variances could impede visibility at the intersection and driveway approach, posing potential safety risks.
During the meeting, the applicant argued that the height of the fence is necessary for security and safety, particularly given the property's unique architectural features and its status as a multi-residential unit with ten units. The applicant emphasized that the fence is predominantly open, which would not obstruct visibility for drivers and pedestrians.
The Board of Adjustment also discussed a related case concerning an appeal to a certificate of appropriateness, which would determine whether the maximum height can be exceeded. The historic design guidelines recommend that front yard fences in historic districts not exceed 4 feet, a standard that the applicant is seeking to surpass.
Community feedback was mixed, with 48 notices mailed out, resulting in one response in favor and one in opposition. The Monte Vista Historical Neighborhood Association expressed opposition to the proposed variances, reinforcing concerns about maintaining the district's historical integrity.
As the Board deliberates on these requests, the implications for the neighborhood's character and safety remain at the forefront of discussions. The outcome of this case will not only affect the applicant but also set a precedent for future requests in the historically significant Monte Vista area. The Board is expected to make a decision in the coming weeks, which will be closely watched by both residents and city officials.
Converted from San Antonio - Board of Adjustment Jun 02, 2025 meeting on June 02, 2025
Link to Full Meeting