Saint Aidan's Church plans to demolish historic Derrick At Wallace House in Milton

In a pivotal meeting held on June 3, 2025, the City of Milton's Design Review Board (DRB) addressed several significant demolition requests, including a historic structure that has sparked community interest and concern. The board convened to discuss the fate of the Derrick At Wallace House, a late 19th-century building located at 13560 Cogburn Road, which is currently owned by Saint Aidan's Episcopal Church.

Father Reggie Simmons, representing the church, presented the case for demolition, citing the house's deteriorating condition and its obscuring presence near the church's main sanctuary. He emphasized that the structure is uninhabitable and that restoration efforts would be financially burdensome for the church. Despite attempts to find a new home for the cottage, including outreach to the Milton Historical Society and local community members, no viable relocation options emerged.

The board reviewed extensive documentation, including photographs showcasing the house's current state, which revealed significant wear and damage. The structure is listed in the Georgia Historic Resources GIS and the City of Milton Historic Survey List, but board members noted that alterations over the years have diminished its historical significance.

After a thorough discussion, which included considerations of community sentiment and the building's historical value, the board ultimately voted to approve the demolition. The decision was met with mixed feelings, as some members expressed a desire to preserve history while acknowledging the practical challenges of maintaining the structure.

In addition to the Cogburn Road case, the board also reviewed several other demolition requests, including properties on Ponytail Road, Freemanville Road, and Dinsmore Road. Each case was met with similar scrutiny regarding the condition of the structures and the intentions of the applicants, with approvals granted based on the presented plans and community support.

As the meeting concluded, the board's decisions highlighted the ongoing balancing act between preserving Milton's historical character and accommodating the evolving needs of its residents. The fate of the Derrick At Wallace House serves as a poignant reminder of the complexities involved in urban development and historical preservation in the community.