Lake Forest City Council approves city manager's salary increase amid public scrutiny

In the heart of Lake Forest, California, the City Council convened on June 3, 2025, to address pressing matters that impact the community. The evening began with a routine approval of previous meeting minutes, but quickly transitioned into a significant public hearing focused on workforce vacancies, recruitment, and retention, mandated by Assembly Bill 2561.

Human Resources Manager Shelly Cisneros presented a detailed overview of the city’s employment landscape, revealing that Lake Forest had 13 vacancies in 2024, with a commendable retention rate of 90%. The city received 558 applications for 14 job postings, showcasing a competitive recruitment effort. The average time to fill these positions was reported at 89 days, aligning well with other public agencies. This presentation underscored the city’s commitment to maintaining a robust workforce, even as it navigates the challenges of public sector employment.

As the meeting progressed, the council turned its attention to a more contentious topic: the seventh amendment to the city manager's employment agreement. Following a positive evaluation, the council proposed a salary increase for City Manager Deborah Rose, raising her base salary to over $322,000 by 2026. While some council members praised Rose's leadership and the city's fiscal health under her management, public comments reflected a stark divide in opinion. One resident expressed strong opposition to the raise, questioning the transparency of the evaluation process and citing concerns over various city management issues.

Despite the dissent, the council ultimately voted in favor of the salary increase, with a 4-1 outcome. Council members defended the decision, highlighting Rose's competence and the stability she brings to the city. The discussion revealed a broader conversation about accountability and transparency in local government, as residents seek clarity on how decisions are made.

As the meeting concluded, it was clear that Lake Forest is at a crossroads, balancing the need for effective leadership with the community's desire for transparency and accountability. The council's decisions will undoubtedly shape the city's future, as residents remain engaged and vocal about the direction they wish to see their community take.