HDC reviews plans for new carriage house and stable on Tripp Drive

In a recent meeting of the Nantucket Historic District Commission (HDC), members gathered to discuss a significant property development on Tripp Drive, a quiet dead-end street. The atmosphere was focused yet collaborative, as Jamie, a representative for the project, guided the commission through the proposed changes with the aid of visual aids.

The project involves the subdivision of a single property into two one-acre lots, with plans to repurpose an existing building into a carriage house on the southern lot, already approved by the commission. The northern lot, currently under review, is less visible from the street, nestled behind landscaping and horse paddocks. Jamie described the layout, noting the presence of a stable that will house eight stalls for horses, along with necessary facilities like a wash stall and tack room.

As the discussion unfolded, one commission member expressed concerns about the design's stylization, suggesting it might not align with the historic character of the area. This prompted a deeper conversation about the appropriateness of the proposed masking and overall aesthetic of the development. The member ultimately decided not to advance the proposal for consent, emphasizing the importance of ensuring that all aspects of the project are thoroughly reviewed.

The meeting highlighted the delicate balance the HDC must maintain between encouraging development and preserving the unique historical charm of Nantucket. As the commission continues to evaluate this project, the outcome will likely set a precedent for future developments in the historic district, reflecting the ongoing dialogue between progress and preservation in this picturesque community.