Mat Su Library Board removes seven books after obscenity ruling

The Matanuska-Susitna Borough Assembly meeting on June 3, 2025, sparked significant debate over library content and proposed tax measures, highlighting community concerns about censorship and fiscal responsibility.

A key discussion centered on the removal of seven books from district library shelves, following a settlement from the Mat Su Scribe Board. The titles, which include popular novels such as "Call Me by Your Name" and "It Ends With Us," were deemed inappropriate for minors under Alaska law. Assembly members noted that the decision was based on findings that these books violated legal standards regarding obscenity. This move has ignited a passionate response from community members, with some arguing that banning books limits access to diverse perspectives and stifles critical discussions on important social issues.

Helen Vincent, a resident of Palmer, passionately defended the importance of books in fostering understanding and empathy. She warned against the dangers of censorship, emphasizing that removing access to controversial topics does not protect youth but rather leaves them unprepared for real-world challenges. Vincent's remarks echoed a broader sentiment among those advocating for open access to literature, arguing that libraries should serve as safe havens for exploration and learning.

In contrast, some community members expressed support for the removal of certain titles, citing concerns about their appropriateness for younger audiences. This division reflects a growing tension within the community regarding the balance between protecting children and preserving freedom of expression.

Additionally, the assembly discussed a proposed 7-cent tax aimed at generating revenue for local projects. Resident Michael Bowles voiced his opposition, cautioning that similar measures in Anchorage had led to misallocation of funds. He urged the assembly to consider alternative revenue sources, particularly with an upcoming LNG project expected to bring significant economic opportunities to the borough.

As the assembly navigates these contentious issues, the implications for local libraries and community funding remain significant. The decisions made in these discussions will shape the future of access to literature and the fiscal landscape of the Matanuska-Susitna Borough, underscoring the importance of community engagement in local governance.