Middletown residents oppose demolition of historic buildings at city council meeting

The City of Middletown Council convened on June 3, 2025, to address several pressing issues, primarily focusing on the future of historic buildings in the downtown area. The meeting featured passionate public comments regarding the proposed demolition of several historically significant structures, including the Manchester Sunshine Building, the First National Bank Building, and the Knights of Columbus Building.

The first speaker, a representative from the Historic South Main Association, emphasized that the council's decision to demolish these buildings contradicts the overwhelming public sentiment favoring preservation. Citing a 2022 survey by the Middletown Historical Society, which indicated that 92% of respondents wished to save the Manchester, the speaker argued that the council's direction conflicts with both public opinion and established city planning documents. These documents advocate for the restoration and repurposing of historic buildings as vital economic and cultural assets.

Subsequent speakers echoed these sentiments, highlighting successful revitalization efforts in comparable cities like Hamilton and Miamisburg. They argued that Middletown could similarly benefit from investing in its historic architecture rather than opting for demolition, which they described as a permanent loss of cultural heritage. One speaker pointed out that the council's arguments for demolition lacked sufficient evidence, questioning the claims of structural instability and economic infeasibility for restoration.

Mary Johnson, chair of Downtown Middletown Inc., reinforced the idea that historic buildings contribute to the community's identity and economic vitality. She urged the council to consider the unique character of downtown Middletown, which cannot be replicated by new construction.

The meeting also addressed concerns about the safety and environmental impact of debris from a recent demolition project on Verity Parkway. A resident expressed frustration over the lack of communication from the city regarding the handling of potentially hazardous materials, emphasizing the need for transparency and community safety.

In addition to discussions on historic preservation, the council heard from Adam Snotty, the principal of the upcoming aviation center at Middletown Regional Airport, who outlined plans for expanding educational opportunities and workforce development in the area.

The meeting concluded with a call for the council to reconsider its approach to downtown revitalization, emphasizing the importance of community engagement and the preservation of Middletown's historical assets. The council's next steps remain to be seen as public sentiment continues to advocate for a more preservation-focused strategy.