The Moreland School District is considering a significant shift in its athletic facilities as discussions about transitioning from natural grass to synthetic turf fields gain momentum. During the Board Study Session on May 27, 2025, key stakeholders evaluated the potential benefits and drawbacks of this change, focusing on player safety, environmental impact, and long-term cost implications.

One of the primary concerns raised was the safety of players on synthetic turf, particularly regarding injuries such as knee issues and skin abrasions. Additionally, the environmental health risks associated with synthetic materials, including the presence of PFAS chemicals and microplastic pollution, were highlighted. These concerns have been increasingly prevalent in discussions across Santa Clara County, prompting the district to carefully weigh its options.

Financially, the district's maintenance costs for natural grass fields are substantial, with estimates of $35,000 annually for middle schools and up to $70,000 for larger facilities. In contrast, synthetic turf maintenance is projected to be lower, with costs estimated at $29,500 for smaller fields and $65,500 for larger ones after an initial learning curve. The anticipated water savings from synthetic turf could also amount to approximately $4,000 annually, further enhancing its appeal.

The board discussed the need for a comprehensive analysis of the total cost of ownership over time, comparing the initial investment in synthetic turf against ongoing maintenance costs for natural grass. This analysis would help determine the long-term financial viability of each option, considering factors such as lifespan and maintenance personnel requirements.

As the Moreland School District moves forward, the decision on whether to adopt synthetic turf will not only impact the budget but also the safety and well-being of its student-athletes. The board plans to continue its evaluation, aiming to make an informed decision that balances financial considerations with community health and safety.