Michigan Environmental Council opposes bill prioritizing landowners over public access rights

During a recent meeting of the Michigan Legislature's Natural Resources and Tourism Committee, significant discussions emerged regarding the balance between property rights and public access to natural resources, particularly in relation to shoreline management. The meeting, held on June 4, 2025, highlighted concerns from both legislators and environmental advocates about the implications of proposed legislation affecting landowners and public access to Michigan's waterways.

Representative Roseanne Saint Germain expressed support for a bill aimed at addressing shoreline erosion, particularly around Lake St. Clair. She raised concerns about the challenges faced by senior citizens who struggle to manage sandbags used for erosion control. Saint Germain emphasized the physical difficulties these individuals encounter, noting that wet sandbags can become heavy and cumbersome, posing health risks due to potential bacteria. Her comments underscored the need for practical solutions that consider the capabilities of vulnerable community members.

In contrast, representatives from the Michigan Environmental Council, Emily Smith and Samantha Pickering, voiced strong opposition to the proposed legislation. They argued that the bill prioritizes landowners' rights over public access to navigable waters, which they believe undermines the public trust doctrine established in Michigan law. This doctrine ensures that citizens have the right to access and enjoy the Great Lakes and other waterways for recreational purposes. Smith and Pickering referenced the Michigan Constitution, which mandates the protection of the state's natural resources and emphasizes the importance of public access for the health and welfare of the community.

The discussions highlighted a critical tension between private property interests and the collective rights of citizens to access and enjoy Michigan's natural resources. As the committee continues to deliberate on this legislation, the implications for both shoreline management and public access remain at the forefront of community concerns. The outcome of these discussions will likely shape future policies regarding environmental protection and resource management in Michigan.