Nogales City Council discusses new wastewater regulation challenges and county's lack of support

In a recent meeting held on June 4, 2025, the City Council of Nogales, Arizona, engaged in a critical discussion regarding the management of wastewater and the implications of new regulatory requirements. The meeting highlighted the complexities surrounding the city's role in handling septic waste, particularly in light of potential costs and administrative burdens.

City Manager Brody Kramer outlined the key requirements set forth by the Arizona Department of Environmental Quality (ADEQ) and the International Boundary and Water Commission (IBWC). He emphasized that the city must ensure all septic haulers provide detailed information about the wastewater they deliver. This includes quarterly reports and compliance with strict discharge restrictions, which could significantly increase operational costs for the city.

Kramer noted that the city is not in the business of losing money and must carefully consider the financial implications of continuing to accept septic waste. He indicated that the county has expressed disinterest in taking on this responsibility, leaving the city to navigate the regulatory landscape alone. The council members expressed concerns about the potential for lawsuits and fines if the city fails to comply with the new regulations.

Councilman Doug Doyle stressed the importance of prioritizing the interests of Nogales residents, arguing against the city’s involvement in septic waste management. He suggested that the city should not be burdened with the complexities of federal and state regulations, especially when the county is unwilling to participate. Doyle's comments reflected a broader sentiment among council members who are wary of the financial and legal risks associated with the city's current wastewater management practices.

The discussion also included public comments, with local resident Rolfo Carranza questioning the council's focus on septic haulers when much of the contamination may originate from industrial waste crossing the border. This point raised concerns about the fairness of placing the burden on local businesses that have demonstrated compliance with regulations.

As the meeting progressed, the council considered a motion to stop accepting septic waste at the current location. However, members acknowledged the need for further discussion and analysis of the costs involved before making a final decision. The council agreed to reconvene with additional information to better understand the implications of their choices.

In conclusion, the meeting underscored the challenges facing the City of Nogales as it navigates new regulatory requirements for wastewater management. With potential financial burdens and legal risks on the horizon, the council must weigh the interests of local residents against the operational realities of managing septic waste. Future discussions will be crucial in determining the city's path forward in this complex issue.