Maui residents oppose Bill 9 citing economic harm and housing implications

Concerns over proposed legislation to phase out short-term rentals (STRs) in Maui County dominated the Housing and Land Use Committee meeting on June 9, 2025. Testimonies from local residents and industry professionals highlighted the potential economic fallout from such a ban, emphasizing the critical role tourism plays in the island's economy.

One STR manager passionately argued that the proposed bill would exacerbate financial struggles for many families reliant on STR income. "Tourism is our lifeblood in Maui," he stated, warning that the loss of STRs could lead to job losses and the closure of beloved local businesses. He pointed out that many residents depend on the revenue generated by these rentals to cover their expenses, with a significant portion of that income staying within the community.

Another resident, Heidi Do, echoed these sentiments, asserting that the bill would not solve the affordable housing crisis but instead harm the local economy. She cited a UHERO report predicting a staggering loss of $900 million in visitor spending and nearly 2,000 local jobs if STRs were phased out. "Bill 9 does not support a better future," she urged, calling for more targeted solutions that would not undermine the economy.

Lynette Pendergast, representing the Realtors Association of Maui, also opposed the bill, emphasizing that it would not achieve its intended goal of increasing affordable housing. She noted that a survey of property owners revealed that only 8% would consider converting their STRs to long-term rentals, with most opting to keep the properties for personal use or sell them. Pendergast warned that the bill could lead to costly legal challenges for the county, further diverting resources from addressing the housing crisis.

As the committee continues to deliberate, the voices of residents and industry stakeholders underscore the complex interplay between housing needs and economic stability in Maui. The outcome of this legislation could have lasting implications for the island's future.