Santa Fe board debates historical status for Mary Austin's well-preserved house

A historic property in Santa Fe is at the center of a heated discussion among city council members, as they consider its designation status and potential renovations. The property, once home to Mary Austin—a pivotal figure in Santa Fe's preservation movement—has been deemed a "contributing" structure rather than "significant," sparking debate over its historical value.

During the June 10 H-Board meeting, staff recommended approval of a proposed project for the property, citing compliance with design standards for historic districts. However, board members expressed surprise at the current designation, noting the building's well-preserved exterior and its historical significance. Built in 1925 and designed by renowned architect John Ka Meehm, the structure retains many original features, leading some members to question whether it should be classified as significant.

One board member highlighted the importance of the building's exterior, stating, "It does have that feel of a significant structure." Another echoed this sentiment, suggesting that the time since the last status review in 1991 warrants a reevaluation. The discussion also touched on the impact of proposed renovations, including a garage, on the building's designation status.

The board ultimately agreed that further investigation into the property's significance is necessary before moving forward with the project. They emphasized the need for a comprehensive review, with one member stating, "It's probably time for a reinvestigation of status." The outcome of this discussion could shape the future of the property and its role in Santa Fe's rich historical landscape.