Georgetown Council Reviews 817 South Austin Avenue Renovation Proposal

Georgetown's City Council made significant strides in historic preservation and urban development during their meeting on June 10, 2025, as they deliberated on the proposed renovations for the building at 817 South Austin Avenue. The council ultimately approved the application, which aims to revitalize the structure while honoring its historical significance.

The discussion centered around the building's windows and facade, with council members and city staff evaluating whether the proposed changes complied with existing design guidelines. The staff reported that while the storefront windows met compliance standards, the overall solid-to-void ratio of the building's facade did not fully align with the guidelines. This led to a broader conversation about the building's historical context and the modifications it has undergone since its original construction in 1920.

Adam Starr, the building's owner, expressed gratitude for the feedback received from the Historic and Architectural Review Commission (HARC) and emphasized his commitment to preserving the building's character. He highlighted the importance of exposing the building's unique double gable trusses, which are considered a significant architectural feature. The design team from LRK, an architecture firm, presented their vision for the building, which includes modern elements while respecting its historical roots.

Public comments reflected a mix of support and opposition. Some residents praised the proposed design for its potential to enhance the visual appeal of the area and attract foot traffic, while others raised concerns about the facade's compatibility with the historic character of the square. Notably, several speakers underscored the importance of maintaining Georgetown's architectural diversity, arguing that the proposed changes could contribute positively to the downtown landscape.

In a notable move, the council approved an amendment to the original motion, which included a request for a plaque recognizing the building's historical significance and its connection to the Lyndall Peterson and Company hardware store. This addition aims to educate the public about the building's history while celebrating its architectural features.

The decision to approve the renovations marks a pivotal moment for Georgetown, as it seeks to balance modern development with the preservation of its rich historical heritage. The council's actions reflect a commitment to fostering a vibrant community that honors its past while looking toward the future.