HARC denies architectural application over gable roof and glass design concerns

The Georgetown City Council meeting on June 10, 2025, focused on a significant appeal regarding a proposed building design alteration that has sparked community debate. The applicant seeks to redesign a historic building by exposing its gable roof, which has been concealed by stucco siding. This proposal has raised concerns among council members and the Historic and Architectural Review Commission (HARC) regarding compliance with local design guidelines.

During the meeting, city staff presented findings indicating that while the application generally complied with the Unified Development Code and the Secretary of Interior Standards, it faced challenges related to the design guidelines, particularly concerning the visibility of the gable roof. Staff emphasized that the proposed design aimed to restore original architectural features but acknowledged that exposing the gable roof deviated from traditional practices in the area, where such roofs are typically hidden behind parapets.

Council members expressed mixed feelings about the design. Some highlighted the importance of maintaining the historical character of the downtown area, noting that exposed gable roofs are not common in the vicinity. Others recognized the value of revealing original architectural elements but questioned whether this approach aligned with established guidelines.

Public sentiment was also a focal point of the discussion. Staff reported a significant number of public comments, with a notable divide between those in favor of the proposal and those opposed. The council was tasked with deciding whether to approve the application as presented, deny it, or approve it with conditions.

In conclusion, the council's decision on this appeal will have implications for the preservation of Georgetown's architectural heritage and the ongoing dialogue about balancing modernization with historical integrity. The council is expected to deliberate further on the matter, weighing community feedback and adherence to design standards before reaching a final decision.