Bexley architecture board reviews Taylor's home renovation proposal amid zoning concerns

During the recent City of Bexley Architectural Review Board meeting held on June 12, 2025, significant discussions centered around a proposed residential project that has drawn both support and concern from board members. The project involves an addition to a home characterized by its distinctive purple color with yellow trim, which has previously been reviewed by the board.

The applicant, represented by Taylor, presented an updated design that maintains the existing footprint of the house while proposing changes primarily in color and materials. The new design aims to create a more cohesive look by matching the addition's colors to those of the existing structure. However, the board raised questions about the architectural balance and massing of the proposed addition, particularly regarding the height and roof design.

Board member Scott expressed approval of the overall massing approach but noted concerns about a large blank wall on the south elevation, suggesting that additional architectural details could enhance the design. Other members, including Hyer and Hall, voiced apprehensions about the potential impact of raising the roof on the neighborhood's character, emphasizing the importance of maintaining architectural harmony in South Bexley, which is known for its historic homes.

Hyer specifically highlighted past projects that had not succeeded in blending with the neighborhood, urging the applicant to reconsider the roof design to avoid dominating the streetscape. The discussion also touched on the need for a streetscape drawing to assess how the new structure would compare in height and scale to neighboring homes.

Ultimately, the board decided to table the application until the next meeting, allowing the applicant time to refine the design and provide additional information, including a streetscape elevation and possibly a 3D rendering. This decision reflects the board's commitment to ensuring that new developments align with the community's architectural standards and character.

The next meeting is scheduled for July 17, 2025, where the applicant will have the opportunity to present revised plans that address the board's feedback. The outcome of this project will be closely watched, as it could set a precedent for future residential additions in the area.