Boise residents oppose church's plan for historical armory site at neighborhood meeting

Concerns over a proposed church development dominated the Planning and Zoning Commission meeting in Boise on June 10, 2025, as residents voiced strong objections to the project’s potential impact on the community. Critics argue that the proposal, which seeks to convert a historically significant site into a single-use religious institution, undermines the opportunity for a vibrant neighborhood activity center that could serve a mix of housing, retail, education, and civic uses.

One resident highlighted that the site, previously identified as a rare chance to create a community-serving space, would instead restrict access to diverse tenants. “This project does not meet the goals of a true neighborhood activity center,” they stated, urging the commission to deny the application. Concerns were also raised about increased traffic, as many congregants reportedly reside outside Boise, in areas like Meridian and Garden City.

Another speaker echoed these sentiments, emphasizing that the neighborhood already has sufficient religious facilities and that the proposed development does not fulfill the mixed-use criteria essential for community growth. They pointed out that the project’s design includes public spaces but fails to address the actual needs of the local residents.

Additionally, the removal of healthy evergreen trees on the site was a significant point of contention, with residents advocating for their preservation. The meeting underscored a broader frustration among community members who feel that the proposal does not align with the city’s planning goals and could detract from the neighborhood’s character.

As the commission deliberates, the future of this site remains uncertain, with residents hopeful for a decision that prioritizes community needs over single-use developments.