Red Hook Town Board faces public outcry over eminent domain plans for boat club

The Town of Red Hook Board of Trustees meeting held on May 13, 2025, focused on significant community concerns, particularly regarding emergency medical services (EMS) and the potential use of eminent domain for local property acquisition.

During the public comment period, residents expressed urgent concerns about the state of EMS in the area. One speaker highlighted the challenges faced by local emergency services, noting that they are currently ordering new equipment due to long wait times for delivery, which could take up to six years and cost approximately $3 million. The speaker urged the board to prioritize funding for EMS, emphasizing the importance of community safety and the need for adequate resources.

Another resident, Matt Donahue, shared his emotional connection to the community and the local boat club, which is at the center of a contentious eminent domain discussion. He argued against the use of eminent domain, stating that it undermines the principles of fairness and community values. Donahue urged the board to reconsider their approach, suggesting that pursuing legal action could lead to prolonged court battles that would ultimately burden taxpayers.

The board members responded to public comments, emphasizing their commitment to transparency and community engagement. They encouraged residents to submit their thoughts in writing to ensure all voices are heard. The board also reiterated their preference for exploring public-private partnerships rather than resorting to eminent domain, indicating that they are still open to negotiations with the boat club regarding the property in question.

As the meeting concluded, the board acknowledged the importance of addressing community concerns and promised further discussions on the matter in upcoming sessions. The ongoing dialogue reflects the town's commitment to balancing development needs with the preservation of community values and resources.