Historic Preservation Commission reviews designation for Saint Timothy's Chapel in Frederick

The Planning Commission Workshop held on June 16, 2025, in Frederick City, Maryland, focused on significant developments regarding historic preservation and community planning. The meeting began with discussions surrounding the potential designation of Saint Timothy's Chapel for a historic preservation overlay. The Historic Preservation Commission (HPC) is set to determine if the site meets the criteria for this designation, which includes factors such as age, historical significance, and architectural integrity. The Planning Commission emphasized its role in considering the HPC's findings, the consistency with the comprehensive plan, and any related planning issues.

Commission members expressed optimism about the chapel's candidacy for designation, citing its historical association with the working-class community and its architectural significance as an early twentieth-century English Gothic building. The discussion highlighted the importance of balancing economic growth with historic preservation, as outlined in the HPC policies.

The meeting also addressed procedural concerns regarding a demolition review for the chapel, where partial demolition had already occurred without prior approval. Staff clarified that while the demolition review process was somewhat out of order, it was necessary to ensure compliance with preservation standards moving forward. The commission noted that the integrity of the building remains largely intact despite recent alterations.

Following this, the commission reviewed a proposal for a new youth center at 300 Scotty's Bus Lane, which is being developed in collaboration with the Osherman Family Foundation. The project aims to serve youth aged 11 to 24 and requires an Institutional Floating Zone (IST) overlay to align with city planning standards. The urgency of the project was underscored, as it needs to be approved before the upcoming primary elections in September.

The meeting concluded with a discussion on a fence modification request for a property at 111 East Second Street. The property owner sought to reinstate a railing on a retaining wall, which had been removed in the past. The commission acknowledged the need for safety compliance while considering the historical context of the property.

Overall, the workshop highlighted the commission's commitment to preserving Frederick's historical assets while facilitating community development, with several key decisions and follow-up actions anticipated in the coming weeks.