Architectural Review Board evaluates design changes for historic West Main Street house

The Historic Zoning Design Review Commission for the City of Franklin engaged in a detailed discussion on June 16, 2025, focusing on the architectural design of a new residential project that has raised concerns among members regarding its height and overall silhouette.

Commissioners expressed apprehension about the proposed porch height, suggesting it appears too tall compared to historical standards. One member noted that inspiration images show porch racks that are lower, often aligning with window heads, which could enhance the building's historical aesthetic. The conversation highlighted the importance of maintaining proportionality in design, especially given the house's prominent location at the crest of the street.

The commission emphasized the need for a balance between modern additions and the preservation of historic forms. They discussed the massing of the structure, with one member suggesting a reduction in height by approximately one to two feet to achieve a more harmonious appearance. The design's impact on the surrounding area was also a key point, as the house's visibility from nearby trails and Magnolia Hall could affect its reception within the community.

Additionally, the commission addressed the porch's depth, recommending a reduction from nine feet to a more traditional six or eight feet, aligning with historical norms. This adjustment aims to ensure that the new construction complements the character of the neighborhood while respecting its historical context.

As the commission continues to refine the design, the focus remains on achieving a balance that honors Franklin's architectural heritage while accommodating modern living needs. The next steps will involve further revisions to the design based on the feedback provided during this meeting.