Franklin DRC reviews historic Miller Beasley House addition proposal

In the heart of Downtown Franklin, a historic discussion unfolded at the Historic Zoning Design Review Commission meeting, where the future of the Miller Beasley House, a cherished structure built in 1866, was at the forefront. As city officials and community members gathered, the atmosphere buzzed with anticipation over proposed renovations that aim to blend modern needs with the preservation of the past.

The property, located at 305 Third Avenue South, is part of the National Register Historic District, which adds a layer of significance to any changes made. The proposal under review included the demolition of a circa 1990 shed, deemed appropriate by the commission, and the addition of a new structure that respects the historical integrity of the original home. The addition, measuring just over 19 feet, adheres to guidelines that recommend it should not exceed one-third of the width of the front facade, ensuring that the historic character remains intact.

Emily, a key speaker at the meeting, highlighted the thoughtful revisions made to the plans based on previous feedback. The new design features brick materials and a standing seam metal roof, harmonizing with the existing architecture. A notable element is the large chimney facing Third Avenue South, designed to evoke the appearance of a smokehouse, a nod to the building's historical context.

However, not all aspects of the proposal received unanimous support. Concerns were raised about the proposed slit windows on the east elevation, which some members felt detracted from the building's original charm. "I'm probably never a fan of the slit windows in a historic district," one commissioner remarked, emphasizing the importance of maintaining a cohesive historical aesthetic.

As the meeting progressed, the commission sought input on the brick detailing of the addition and the size of the vents, underscoring the collaborative nature of the review process. The discussions reflected a commitment to preserving Franklin's rich history while accommodating contemporary needs.

With the commission's deliberations still ongoing, the future of the Miller Beasley House hangs in the balance, embodying the delicate dance between progress and preservation in a city that values its heritage. As the community watches closely, the outcome of this proposal could set a precedent for how historic structures are adapted for modern use, ensuring that Franklin's past continues to inform its future.