Apopolo Lehi Council denies appeal to replace historic windows at 224 East Fillmore Street

The Petersburg City Council convened on June 17, 2025, to address several agenda items, with a significant focus on a public hearing regarding an appeal from Michael Nick concerning the Architectural Review Board's (ARB) decision on the windows of a property located at 224 East Fillmore Street in the Apopolo Lehi Historic District.

The meeting began with Planning Director Naomi Saadmock outlining the appeal, which contested the ARB's determination that nine front windows should be repaired rather than replaced. The applicant, Michael Nick, argued for the replacement of all windows with wood-clad and aluminum options, citing safety concerns for future tenants of the rental property. He emphasized that the existing windows were non-functional, posing a risk in emergency situations.

During the public hearing, Bill Hartsock, a member of the ARB, supported the board's decision, stating that the front windows were in good condition and could be preserved. He noted that while the rear and side windows could be replaced, the front ones contributed significantly to the building's historic character and should be repaired to maintain that integrity.

Council members engaged in a robust discussion, weighing the importance of historical preservation against safety concerns. Councilman Jones expressed strong support for replacing the windows, highlighting the potential dangers of non-working windows in a rental property. He argued that safety should take precedence over aesthetic considerations.

After deliberation, Councilman Cuthbert moved to affirm the ARB's decision to repair the windows, which was seconded by Councilwoman Smith Lee. The council voted, resulting in a majority in favor of upholding the ARB's ruling, with the motion carrying despite dissent from Councilman Jones.

The meeting concluded with the council's decision reflecting a commitment to preserving the historic character of Petersburg while navigating the complexities of safety and functionality in residential properties.