Butte residents debate new Airbnb proposal amid neighborhood concerns

The Butte-Silver Bow Zoning Board of Adjustments meeting on June 17, 2025, brought to light significant community concerns regarding a proposed short-term rental in a residential neighborhood. The application, presented by a local resident, aimed to convert a five-bedroom home into an Airbnb, sparking a heated discussion among board members and community members alike.

The applicant emphasized their commitment to maintaining the neighborhood's character, stating that they had already met several neighbors and planned to limit the rental's impact by enforcing strict parking rules and noise restrictions. They assured the board that they would only rent to verified guests and would monitor the property with security cameras to prevent disturbances.

However, several neighbors voiced strong opposition to the proposal. Gary McWhorter, a resident living adjacent to the property, expressed concerns about potential disruptions, safety issues, and the impact on the long-standing residential nature of the area. He argued that the introduction of a short-term rental could lead to increased traffic and a transient population, which he believed would undermine the community's stability.

Linda Trevenna, another neighbor, echoed these sentiments, highlighting the recent influx of young families in the neighborhood and questioning why the applicant had not considered the ramifications of operating a rental before purchasing the property. Chad Joanard, a parent in the area, also raised safety concerns, particularly regarding parking and the potential for increased traffic from short-term guests.

In response to the opposition, the applicant acknowledged the concerns raised and reiterated their intention to be a responsible neighbor. They pointed out that short-term rentals already exist in Butte and argued that they could bring economic benefits to the community through tourism.

The board's decision on the application remains pending, as they weigh the potential benefits of the rental against the concerns of local residents. This meeting highlights the ongoing debate in Butte-Silver Bow about balancing economic development with preserving the character of established neighborhoods. As the community continues to grow and change, the outcomes of such discussions will play a crucial role in shaping the future of residential areas in Butte.