On June 11, 2025, the Town of Brookhaven's Zoning Board convened to address several significant matters, including a contentious discussion regarding a deer fence erected in a historic district without proper authorization. The meeting highlighted community concerns about adherence to zoning regulations and the preservation of local heritage.

The primary focus of the meeting was a complaint from a resident living near Shore Road, who expressed frustration over the construction of a deer fence by their neighbors, the Gramas. The resident argued that the fence was built illegally and violated the integrity of the historic district. They emphasized that no other property in the area had erected such a fence, raising concerns about the potential precedent this could set for future developments. The resident's testimony underscored a broader issue of compliance with building codes and the importance of maintaining the character of historic neighborhoods.

In response, Ms. DeVito, representing the Gramas, stated that she believed the property was not within the jurisdiction of the historic district and that no comments had been received from the Historic District Advisory Committee (HDAC) regarding the fence. This exchange highlighted the complexities of zoning regulations and the challenges residents face when navigating local governance.

The board ultimately decided to close and hold the discussion, indicating that further deliberation would be necessary before a final decision could be made. This decision reflects the board's commitment to thoroughly review the implications of the fence and its impact on the community.

In addition to the deer fence issue, the meeting also addressed a separate application for residential additions on Scotts Grove Lane. The applicant, John Rose, sought permission for multiple expansions to his property, which included a second-story addition and modifications to an existing sunroom. This application was presented by Diane Mosier, who noted that the property was built in 1971 and required variances for the proposed changes.

The discussions from this meeting illustrate the ongoing tension between individual property rights and community standards in Brookhaven. As the board continues to evaluate these applications, the outcomes will likely influence future zoning decisions and the preservation of the town's historic character. The next steps will involve further examination of the deer fence situation and the residential additions, with the board expected to reconvene to reach resolutions on these matters.