Midlothian City Council denies ice cream shop expansion in Old Town area

The Midlothian City Council meeting on June 24, 2025, focused on a proposed development project that has sparked significant community interest and concern. The primary discussion revolved around the potential expansion of Midlow Scoops, an ice cream shop, into a new building that would also include a sweet tea shop. Council members and residents expressed apprehensions regarding traffic, parking, noise, and the overall impact on the surrounding residential area.

During the meeting, it was noted that the proposed development would require a substantial number of parking spots, with calculations suggesting a need for at least seven spaces based on the size of the new building. Concerns were raised about the adequacy of parking and the potential for increased traffic congestion in the area, particularly given the proximity to residential neighborhoods and local schools.

Noise regulations were also a significant topic of discussion. Currently, state law allows noise levels up to 85 decibels at property lines, which some council members felt was too high. The council explored the possibility of implementing stricter noise and lighting regulations, especially in residential areas, but acknowledged the challenges in enforcing such measures.

The council members emphasized the importance of finding a balance between supporting local businesses and addressing the concerns of residents. Several council members expressed a desire for the developers to consider concessions, such as limiting outdoor seating and noise levels, to mitigate the impact on the community.

Ultimately, the council decided to deny the proposal without prejudice, allowing the developers to reapply in the future with potentially revised plans. A workshop will be scheduled to facilitate further discussions between the developers and community members, aiming to address the concerns raised during the meeting.

This decision reflects the council's commitment to ensuring that development aligns with the needs and expectations of the community while fostering local business growth. The outcome of the workshop will be crucial in determining the future of the proposed expansion and its integration into the Old Town area of Midlothian.