Council member advocates mayoral primary amid concerns of too many candidates

In a recent special meeting of the Billings City Council held on June 16, 2025, discussions centered around the potential implementation of a primary election for the mayoral race. The meeting highlighted differing opinions among council members regarding the necessity and implications of a primary, particularly in a scenario where four candidates are vying for the position.

One council member expressed initial hesitation about supporting a primary but ultimately leaned towards favoring it, citing concerns about the clarity of choice for voters. They argued that having four candidates could complicate the election process, making it difficult for voters to discern their preferred choice. The member suggested that a primary could streamline the election by narrowing the field to two candidates, thereby enhancing voter understanding and engagement.

Another significant point raised during the meeting was the perception of integrity among the candidates involved in the discussion. One council member noted that it might have been prudent for the three candidates to recuse themselves from the conversation to avoid any conflicts of interest. This concern underscores the importance of maintaining public trust in the electoral process, especially when personal stakes are involved.

While the council member acknowledged the challenges posed by a four-candidate race, they also highlighted the financial implications of holding a primary election, estimating the cost at around $100,000. This financial consideration adds another layer of complexity to the decision-making process, as council members weigh the benefits of a clearer electoral choice against the costs associated with conducting a primary.

As the meeting concluded, it became evident that while there was support for a primary election focused solely on the mayoral race, the proposal faced uncertainty regarding its passage. The discussions reflect ongoing concerns about electoral integrity, voter clarity, and fiscal responsibility, all of which will play a crucial role in shaping the upcoming election landscape in Billings. The council's next steps will be closely watched as they navigate these important issues.