Winter Haven residents oppose police partnership with ICE at city commission meeting

During the City Commission Meeting on June 23, 2025, in Winter Haven, a significant discussion emerged regarding a proposed agreement between the Winter Haven Police Department and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Residents voiced strong opposition to the agreement, expressing concerns about its potential impact on community safety and trust in law enforcement.

Matthew Crowley, a lifelong resident and public school employee, was among the first to speak against the proposal. He argued that allowing local police to act as federal immigration agents would create fear among residents, particularly those from immigrant backgrounds. Crowley emphasized that this could deter individuals from reporting crimes, such as domestic violence, due to fears of deportation. He warned that such agreements have historically led to racial profiling and a breakdown of trust between communities and law enforcement.

Other community members echoed Crowley’s sentiments. Juanita Zwarchuk, a frequent visitor to Winter Haven, expressed her concerns about the broader implications of the agreement, suggesting it could set a precedent for neighboring cities. She urged the commission to prioritize policies that foster trust and safety for all residents.

Tina Polk Kinnemoth, a long-time resident, highlighted the human aspect of the issue, reminding the commission that many immigrants contribute positively to the community. She questioned the necessity of the agreement and called for a focus on community policing rather than federal immigration enforcement.

The meeting also featured voices like Marleah Yates and Louis Davila, who reiterated the dangers of entangling local law enforcement with federal immigration duties. They argued that such actions would not only undermine public safety but also lead to civil rights abuses and increased racial profiling.

As the commission deliberates on this matter, the community's strong opposition reflects a desire for a more inclusive approach to public safety—one that prioritizes trust and cooperation over fear and division. The outcome of this discussion could significantly shape the relationship between law enforcement and the diverse residents of Winter Haven.