Garment District advocates oppose MSMX housing plan citing business displacement risks

The Subcommittee on Zoning and Franchises convened in New York City on July 1, 2025, to discuss the controversial MSMX proposal, which aims to develop approximately 9,700 new homes, including 2,900 affordable units, in the Garment District. However, the plan has sparked significant opposition from local stakeholders who fear it could jeopardize the area's unique cultural and economic fabric.

Orly Nativ, a costume designer and advocate for the Garment District, voiced strong concerns about the potential displacement of small businesses and artisans that are vital to the fashion and theater industries. "The Garment District is deserving of protection," Nativ stated, emphasizing that the current proposal lacks safeguards for existing businesses, which could lead to their disruption and loss. She highlighted the importance of maintaining the district's vibrant community of independent creators who rely on local resources.

Renee Cafaro, a fashion designer and business owner in the area, echoed these sentiments, arguing that the MSMX plan fails to address the needs of the garment industry. "We need to prioritize affordability for both housing and commercial spaces," she urged, calling for a balanced approach that supports both living and working conditions for creatives. Cafaro criticized the perception that the Garment District is dying, asserting that it remains a bustling hub for thousands of workers.

The discussions underscored a critical tension between the urgent need for affordable housing and the preservation of the Garment District's unique character. Stakeholders are calling for revisions to the MSMX proposal to ensure it supports the local economy while still addressing housing shortages. As the city moves forward, the outcome of this debate will significantly impact the future of both the Garment District and its residents.