Columbia County Library Board faces backlash over new controversial policies

The Columbia County Board of Commissioners meeting on July 1, 2025, featured intense discussions surrounding recent changes to library policies and the impact on staff and community members. The meeting highlighted concerns over the establishment of a new regional library board, which has yet to appoint members, leading to accusations of creating a "shell" board that operates without public oversight.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to public comments from concerned citizens, including library staff and patrons, who expressed their dissatisfaction with the new guidelines imposed on library operations. Critics argued that these policies have fostered a toxic work environment, resulting in a mass exodus of library employees. One speaker noted that the Evans branch has lost its children's librarian and half of its circulation staff, raising alarms about the library's ability to serve the community effectively.

Concerns were also raised about the handling of book reconsiderations, with accusations that the process was rushed and lacked transparency. Specific titles, including the graphic novel "Gender Queer," were cited as examples of books that were improperly categorized, leading to confusion and frustration among library users. Critics emphasized that the guidelines do not protect children but instead create barriers to essential discussions about body awareness and safety.

Supporters of the new policies defended the changes, arguing for the need to appoint qualified individuals to the library board. One speaker urged the commissioners to ensure that future appointments include experts in library science, emphasizing the importance of knowledgeable leadership in guiding library operations.

The meeting concluded with a call for the board to reconsider the recent policy changes, with community members urging a return to a more inclusive and professional approach to library management. The ongoing debate reflects broader tensions within the community regarding access to information and the role of public libraries in fostering diverse viewpoints. As the board moves forward, the implications of these discussions will likely continue to resonate within Columbia County.