Delray Beach Board debates historic siding replacement using synthetic materials

In a recent meeting of the Delray Beach Historic Preservation Board, significant discussions centered around the replacement of siding on a historic structure, raising concerns about compliance with preservation standards and the integrity of the building's historical character. The board reviewed a case where the entire siding of a building was replaced without a permit, prompting a debate on the appropriateness of using synthetic materials versus authentic wood.

The building department indicated that the property owner could either provide a Notice of Acceptance (NOA) or a letter from a licensed professional to confirm that the new materials meet Florida building codes, particularly regarding hurricane wind load requirements. However, the board emphasized the importance of adhering to the Secretary of the Interior's standards, which recommend retaining original materials whenever possible to preserve the historic integrity of structures.

During the meeting, board members expressed concerns about the aesthetic and structural implications of replacing wood siding with a composite material. They noted that while the new material may appear visually appealing, it lacks the authentic texture and profile of the original wood, which is crucial for maintaining the building's historical significance. The board referenced previous cases where careful restoration efforts were made to preserve original siding, highlighting the importance of authenticity in historic districts.

Public comments reflected a mix of opinions, with some residents acknowledging the challenges of maintaining historic properties while others urged the board to uphold preservation standards. One property owner even suggested they would be willing to accept a non-contributing status for their building if it meant receiving approval for their siding replacement.

As the board deliberates on this matter, they are tasked with balancing the need for compliance with modern building codes against the imperative to protect the historical character of Delray Beach's architectural heritage. The outcome of this discussion could set a precedent for future renovations in the area, underscoring the ongoing tension between preservation and modernization in historic districts.