Goshen Board denies variance request for permanent structure amid code violations

The Zoning Board Meeting held on July 1, 2025, in Goshen, NY, focused on critical discussions regarding area variances and adherence to local zoning codes. The meeting highlighted the board's commitment to maintaining zoning regulations while addressing individual applicant circumstances.

One of the primary discussions involved a request for an area variance related to a permanent structure that had been constructed without proper permits. Board members expressed their concerns about the implications of granting such variances, emphasizing the importance of following established codes to prevent future violations. A board member with over three decades of experience noted that each case is unique, but stressed that the current situation did not meet the necessary criteria for approval.

The board ultimately voted against granting the variance, with a 3-2 decision. The chairperson indicated that while the decision was difficult, it was necessary to uphold the integrity of the zoning code. A written decision detailing the board's reasoning will be made available within 30 days.

During the meeting, the applicants expressed their frustration and concern about the potential demolition of their structure, which they had invested significant time and resources into. The board advised them to consult with the building department for guidance on the next steps, reiterating that the decision was based on adherence to zoning laws rather than personal circumstances.

The meeting concluded with a reminder of the importance of compliance with zoning regulations, as the board prepares to address further public hearings in the future. The discussions underscored the balance the board seeks to maintain between individual property rights and community standards.