Lightning Society seeks approval for private member's club and catering space in Soho

The Manhattan Community Board 2's SLA Committee meeting on July 1, 2025, focused on two significant applications for event spaces in Soho, raising concerns about noise, safety, and community impact.

The first application discussed was for a venue seeking to operate as a full-service event space, offering food, staffing, and entertainment, including live music and DJs. The venue's representatives stated they could accommodate up to 185 people, although typical events would host around 40 to 80 attendees. They assured the committee that soundproofing measures were in place, citing a lack of complaints during previous operations. However, committee members expressed skepticism about the venue's ability to manage large crowds and the adequacy of its soundproofing, especially given the building's mixed-use nature.

The second application was presented by the Center for Emerging Culture, proposing a private members' club with a focus on arts and culture. The founder emphasized a commitment to community engagement and cultural programming, distancing the new venture from a previous tenant, the House of Cannabis, which had faced significant community backlash. The club aims to host events that foster conversation and creativity, but concerns were raised about the potential for noise and disruption in the residential neighborhood.

Public comments reflected a divide in community sentiment. Supporters of the applications highlighted the potential for revitalizing the area and fostering cultural events, while opponents voiced strong objections, fearing that the venues would transform the neighborhood into a party district, compromising its character and tranquility. Residents expressed concerns about noise, safety, and the preservation of Soho's unique atmosphere.

The committee concluded the meeting without making a decision, indicating that further discussions and evaluations would be necessary to address the community's concerns and the operational viability of both applications. The outcome of these proposals remains uncertain as the board continues to weigh the interests of local residents against the potential benefits of new cultural spaces in the area.