McKinney home faces demolition after foundation repair mishap causes severe damage

The McKinney Historic Preservation Advisory Board convened on July 3, 2025, to address the urgent matter of a historic home that suffered significant damage during a foundation repair attempt. The board reviewed a request for the demolition of the structure, which had fallen approximately three feet, resulting in extensive damage to its walls and foundation.

During the meeting, staff presented detailed photographs illustrating the home's previous condition alongside its current state, highlighting the twisted and warped structure. The engineering report indicated that the integrity of the building had been compromised, making any further attempts to restore it likely to cause additional damage. As a result, staff recommended approval for the demolition.

The property owner, who had purchased the home from the family of a beloved local school teacher, expressed deep regret over the situation. He shared his plans to salvage materials from the house, including hardwood floors and decorative trim, to incorporate into a new structure that would honor the original design. He emphasized his commitment to preserving the home's historical essence, despite the challenges faced.

The board discussed the emotional impact of the loss on the community, acknowledging the home's historical significance and the memories associated with it. Members expressed their support for the owner's rebuilding efforts, recognizing the importance of maintaining the character of McKinney's historic neighborhoods.

The board ultimately has four options regarding the demolition request: approve, approve with conditions, deny, or issue a 90-day delay. The decision will play a crucial role in determining the future of the property and the preservation of its historical legacy. As the community looks ahead, the owner’s dedication to rebuilding offers a glimmer of hope for the restoration of this cherished landmark.