In a recent San Francisco government meeting, taxi permit holders voiced their deep concerns regarding the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency's (SFMTA) handling of taxi medallion appeals. The meeting highlighted a growing tension between the SFMTA and taxi drivers, particularly those with disabilities or long-standing service records.

Several speakers, including long-time taxi drivers, expressed frustration over the SFMTA's recent decisions to revoke medallions and deny appeals, despite previous rulings that favored the drivers. One speaker, George Orville, who has been a cab driver for over four decades and is now wheelchair-bound, described the agency's actions as an "unconscionable power grab." He emphasized that the right to appeal medallion revocations has been enshrined in the San Francisco city charter since 1932, and he criticized the SFMTA for disregarding this established right.

Another driver, Marcela Fonseca, echoed these sentiments, accusing the SFMTA of being vindictive towards permit holders who had previously won appeals. She urged the board to challenge the city attorney's assertion that the SFMTA could terminate drivers' rights to appeal, calling for a restoration of these rights to prevent further abuses of power.

Mark Paulson, an 81-year-old medallion holder, raised concerns about the legality of the SFMTA's actions, particularly regarding the agency's insistence on drug and alcohol testing for elderly and disabled drivers who are no longer operating vehicles. He argued that this policy violates constitutional rights and called for a thorough examination of the SFMTA's practices.

The meeting underscored a critical moment for taxi drivers in San Francisco, as they seek to regain their rights and ensure fair treatment from the SFMTA. The ongoing disputes over medallion appeals and the agency's authority raise significant questions about the balance of power between city agencies and the rights of individual drivers. As the situation develops, the taxi community remains hopeful for a resolution that honors their long-standing rights and contributions to the city's transportation landscape.