The July 4, 2025, meeting of the San Francisco Planning Commission focused on the Great Highway Pilot Project, which seeks to secure a coastal zone permit for a temporary restriction on automobile access along a two-mile stretch of the Upper Great Highway. This initiative aims to create a car-free promenade for pedestrians and cyclists on weekends and holidays, a measure initially implemented in response to the COVID-19 pandemic in April 2020.

Alex Westhoff from the Planning Department presented the project, detailing its evolution from a full closure to a modified schedule that allows vehicle access during weekdays. The Board of Supervisors had previously passed an ordinance in December 2022 to maintain these restrictions until December 31, 2025. The project also includes traffic calming measures to enhance pedestrian safety in surrounding neighborhoods.

Brian Stockel from the Recreation and Parks Department elaborated on the pilot's objectives, emphasizing its role in studying visitor usage and traffic conditions. Since its inception, the pilot has recorded over 2.8 million visits, indicating strong community engagement. The project aligns with the Ocean Beach Master Plan and aims to improve public access to coastal areas.

Public comments during the meeting reflected a divided community. Supporters highlighted the benefits of the pilot, including increased recreational opportunities and community events, while opponents raised concerns about traffic congestion, environmental impacts, and the need for a comprehensive environmental impact report (EIR). Many residents expressed fears that the pilot could lead to permanent restrictions on vehicle access, potentially harming local traffic flow and emergency response times.

The commission is expected to deliberate on the permit application, with a recommendation for approval from the Planning Department, contingent on certain conditions. The outcome of this meeting will influence the future of the Great Highway and its role in San Francisco's transportation and recreational landscape.