San Francisco conducts audit to improve Alameda Farmers Market operations and governance

The San Francisco County government meeting highlighted significant findings from a performance audit of the Alemany Farmers Market, the only city-operated market in San Francisco. The audit, initiated by Supervisor Maxwell, aimed to assess the market's effectiveness and efficiency, revealing areas for improvement that could enhance the experience for both vendors and customers.

Key findings from the audit indicated that the market lacks a clear mission statement, which has hindered its ability to align with broader city goals such as promoting healthy living and supporting small businesses. The market has experienced management instability, with oversight shifting among four different city departments over the past seven years. This inconsistency has contributed to ongoing challenges, including inadequate security measures, insufficient parking, and deteriorating infrastructure.

Financially, the Alemany Farmers Market generates enough revenue to cover its expenses and contribute approximately $400,000 annually to the city’s general fund. However, the audit pointed out that there is a lack of formal planning for necessary investments in the market's facilities, which are in need of repair. Issues such as poor signage and the absence of a perimeter fence were also noted as areas requiring immediate attention.

The governance structure of the market was found to be ineffective, with existing rules not fully compliant with state and city regulations. The audit recommended establishing a formal advisory committee for vendor participation and a more equitable fee structure for food vendors, who currently pay varying rates for the same stall size.

Compliance with health and safety regulations was another critical concern, as the market has faced multiple citations for noncompliance over the past three years. The audit emphasized the need for better training and resources for market staff to ensure adherence to state and local laws.

In conclusion, the audit presents a roadmap for enhancing the Alemany Farmers Market, which has been a staple of the community since its establishment in 1943. By addressing these findings, the city aims to improve the market's operations, ensuring it remains a valuable resource for residents and local farmers alike. The next steps will involve collaboration between the Real Estate Division and other city departments to implement the recommended changes and foster a more vibrant market experience.