The San Francisco Historic Preservation Commission has recommended approval for a significant alteration to the St. Francis Hotel, proposing the addition of two steel-framed pergolas at the second-floor balconies. This move aims to enhance the hotel's outdoor spaces while maintaining the historic integrity of the iconic structure, built in 1904 and a staple of Union Square.

The proposed pergolas, designed to be 11 feet 2 inches tall, will be strategically placed to avoid obstructing the ornate string course above the second floor. They will be recessed from the historic ornamental railing and the Powell Street property line, ensuring that the character-defining features of the hotel remain intact. The project also includes downcast lighting and heaters, finished in a dark low gloss paint to blend seamlessly with the hotel's aesthetic.

Commissioners expressed mixed feelings during the meeting. While some voiced support for the project as a means to invigorate Union Square and enhance the hotel's functionality, others raised concerns about the visibility of the pergolas and their impact on the historic facade. Commissioner Wright questioned the necessity of the pergolas, suggesting that they might not be essential for the balconies' success, given the limited sunlight in the area.

The hotel management and the architectural team from Stanton Architecture defended the project, emphasizing its role in creating a vibrant space that would attract visitors and enhance the hotel's offerings. They noted that the pergolas would not only provide shelter but also serve as a modern design element that distinguishes the new from the old.

The commission ultimately decided to continue the discussion, allowing for further exploration of design options, including the possibility of adjusting the pergola's orientation to minimize visual impact. This decision reflects a broader commitment to revitalizing Union Square, a key area in San Francisco that has faced challenges in recent years. The outcome of this proposal could set a precedent for future developments in the historic district, balancing modernization with preservation.