The San Francisco Planning Commission convened on July 4, 2025, to address a significant housing issue involving the eviction of tenants from in-law units amid the ongoing housing crisis. The meeting highlighted the emotional and legal complexities surrounding unauthorized dwelling units (UDUs) and the implications for tenants facing eviction.

Commissioner Swig recounted a personal experience that underscored the urgency of the situation, noting that individuals living in illegal but habitable units were being removed without notice, contributing to the city's homelessness problem. He emphasized the importance of legislation that protects tenants from eviction and demolition, which has evolved into current discussions about accessory dwelling units (ADUs).

The commission discussed a specific case involving a family caregiver facing eviction while caring for a relative with dementia. Commissioner Trezvino expressed sympathy for the caregiver's plight and pointed out that the planning department had not received complete information regarding the tenant's status at the time the demolition permit was applied for. This lack of transparency led to a defective application process.

Commissioner Lundberg echoed these concerns, labeling the case as one of the most egregious he had encountered in his extensive experience as a tenant attorney. He urged the planning department and the Department of Building Inspection (DBI) to investigate the permit holder's documentation for potential civil or criminal penalties.

Ultimately, the commission voted unanimously to grant the appeal, revoking the demolition permit based on the incomplete information provided during the application process. This decision reflects the commission's commitment to upholding tenant rights and addressing the broader housing crisis in San Francisco. The outcome serves as a reminder of the ongoing challenges faced by tenants in the city and the importance of vigilance in the enforcement of housing regulations.