The San Francisco Historic Preservation Commission convened on July 4, 2025, to discuss a significant request for a certificate of appropriateness concerning the property at 1737 Webster Street, located within the Bush Street Cottage Row historic district. The meeting focused on a proposed rehabilitation project for the Volmer House, a notable stick Eastlake style residence built circa 1876.

The property, which was individually listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1973, has a rich history, including its relocation from Turk Street due to redevelopment efforts. The proposed project aims to enhance the home by adding a fourth story, a rear horizontal extension, and a new residential unit on the ground floor, while maintaining the integrity of the building's historic features.

The project plans include matching the new siding to the existing wood horizontal siding and ensuring that new windows on secondary elevations will also be wood. Notably, the front facade will remain unaltered, preserving the building's distinctive architectural character. The fourth-story addition will be set back significantly from the building face, and new skylights and solar panels will be discreetly mounted.

During the meeting, staff presented their analysis, recommending approval of the project based on its compliance with preservation standards. However, the commission noted that they had received mixed feedback from the community, including two letters of support and three letters of opposition. The opposition primarily stemmed from concerns regarding the potential visual impact of the new additions on neighboring properties.

The homeowners, Harlan and Audrey Crystal, expressed their commitment to preserving the historic significance of the Volmer House while accommodating their growing family's needs. They emphasized their collaboration with experienced architects and their efforts to minimize the visual impact of the proposed changes.

Public comments included support from local residents and concerns from others regarding the potential effects of the new construction on the historic district's character. The commission will continue to review the project, considering both the preservation of the building's historical integrity and the community's feedback.

The meeting concluded with a commitment to further discussions and evaluations, ensuring that the project aligns with the goals of historic preservation while addressing the needs of the current homeowners.