The San Francisco City Commission convened on July 4, 2025, to discuss a proposed installation of a DISH wireless telecommunications facility atop a 26-story mixed-use building located at the northwest corner of Otis and Twelfth Street. The project involves the addition of three antennas, which will be housed within two radome covers, each with a maximum height of 42 inches, along with ancillary equipment enclosed by an eight-foot tall structure.

The existing building, completed in 2021, features 2,200 square feet of retail space, 16,000 square feet dedicated to arts activities, a theater for the city ballet school, and 416 residential units. The proposed facility is expected to cast a minimal increase in shadow on the nearby Eleventh and Natoma Park, raising the shadow load by just 0.003% above current levels.

For the project to proceed, the commission must adopt shadow findings indicating that the additional shadow on the park is not significant or adverse, as per planning code section 295. Additionally, a conditional use authorization is required for the facility, which exceeds the height limit of 25 feet above roof grade.

The planning department has determined that the project aligns with the Market and Octavia Area Plan, the Downtown Area Plan, and the general plan's objectives. It is also seen as beneficial for public safety, enhancing wireless communication services in the area, particularly during emergencies.

During the meeting, commissioners raised concerns about the potential impact on the park, particularly regarding the children's playground. The project sponsor, Eric Lentz, explained that alternative locations on the rooftop were explored but were not viable due to existing structures and equipment. The design was modified to reduce the overall massing and shadow impact, which was confirmed by the planning staff.

The Recreation and Parks Commission had previously reviewed the project and expressed no concerns regarding the shadow impact, noting that the additional shadow would occur during late afternoon in winter months when sunlight is already limited.

After thorough discussion, the commission unanimously approved the project, emphasizing the importance of minimizing future shadow impacts on the park. The motion to adopt the shadow findings and approve the project with conditions passed with a vote of 5-0. The meeting then transitioned to the next agenda item.