The San Francisco Planning Commission convened on July 4, 2025, to discuss an appeal regarding a building permit for a vertical addition to a single-family home in the Bernal Heights neighborhood. The meeting featured presentations from the Planning Department and the Department of Building Inspection, both of which supported the permit's approval.

Corey Teague, the zoning administrator, outlined the specifics of the project, which involves a one-story vertical addition that adheres to the zoning regulations of the RH 1 District and the Bernal Heights Special Use District. He emphasized that the addition is modest and complies with the residential design guidelines, noting that it does not extend to the full footprint of the existing home. Teague addressed concerns raised by an appellant regarding the impact on a north-facing kitchen window, stating that the existing window already receives limited light due to its location and the uphill position of the property.

Teague further explained that the Bernal Heights area has unique zoning controls aimed at maintaining the neighborhood's character, including mass reduction requirements that limit the overall size of buildings. He confirmed that the proposed addition is well within these limits and does not require a variance.

Matthew Green from the Department of Building Inspection reiterated that the permit had been thoroughly reviewed by multiple agencies, including fire and public works, and was found to comply with all relevant codes. He also stated that there are no additional special conditions imposed by the building code for this neighborhood.

The commission's discussions highlighted the balance between individual property rights and community standards, with both departments advocating for the denial of the appeal and the upholding of the permit. The outcome of this meeting underscores the ongoing efforts to manage development in San Francisco while respecting the unique characteristics of its neighborhoods.