Historic Commission debates new siding materials for landmark renovations

The German Village Commission held a special meeting on July 2, 2025, focusing on several key applications for exterior building alterations that could significantly impact the historic character of the neighborhood.

One of the primary discussions centered around the use of siding materials for historic structures. The commission emphasized the importance of selecting materials that closely resemble traditional wood siding, as they aim to maintain the aesthetic integrity of the historic district. The commission expressed concerns about the durability and appearance of certain synthetic materials, particularly fiber cement siding, which they noted tends to warp and does not hold up well over time. Instead, they are exploring the use of LP SmartSide composites, which have shown promise in test cases, and are considering adding them to the list of approved materials pending further evaluation.

Another significant topic was the application for exterior alterations at 750 South Wazelle Street, where the applicant proposed to replace deteriorating siding with new cedar horizontal lap siding. The commission recommended continuing the application to allow for further review of the existing conditions and to ensure compliance with the German Village guidelines. The applicant was open to suggestions and willing to consider alternative siding types that align with the commission's preferences.

Additionally, the commission reviewed a proposal for a new kitchen addition at 180 Reinhardt, which involves demolishing a non-historic garage and constructing a new one-story addition. This project aligns with previous approvals and aims to enhance the functionality of the existing structure while adhering to the neighborhood's architectural standards.

The meeting concluded with a commitment to continue evaluating siding materials and ensuring that any alterations made to historic properties respect the character and guidelines of the German Village. The commission's careful consideration of these applications reflects their dedication to preserving the unique heritage of the community while accommodating necessary updates to residential properties.