City Council approves rezone for mixed-use development near Karcher

The Caldwell City Council convened on July 8, 2025, to discuss several key agenda items, primarily focusing on a proposed development project that has undergone significant revisions. The meeting began with a presentation from developers advocating for a new site plan, which they believe better aligns with the community's needs and the city's comprehensive plan.

The developers emphasized that their revised proposal significantly reduces the number of residential units from the original plan of 301 to 152, addressing previous concerns about high-density housing in the area. They argued that the new plan respects the established character of the neighborhood and aims to create a cohesive and inviting community. The developers also noted that the mixed-use product they initially proposed had not been successful in the market, prompting the shift to a more viable solution.

Council members engaged in a detailed discussion regarding the implications of the proposed changes. Some expressed concerns about the reduction in density and the potential impact on local schools and traffic. However, others highlighted that the revised plan would alleviate some of the previous issues associated with higher density, making it a more favorable option for the community.

Councilor Register raised the importance of gathering more feedback from local residents, particularly those who had previously opposed multifamily developments in the area. She suggested extending the public comment period to ensure that community voices were heard before making a final decision. The council agreed to consider this request, indicating a willingness to engage with the community further.

Ultimately, the council voted unanimously to approve the revised development plan, incorporating conditions to maintain the commercial aspects of the project as previously outlined. This decision reflects a consensus that the new proposal is a better fit for the neighborhood compared to the original high-density plan.

The meeting concluded with the council moving on to housekeeping items related to the approved rezone, ensuring that the necessary legislative steps were taken to formalize the changes discussed. The council's actions indicate a commitment to balancing development with community input and maintaining the character of Caldwell's neighborhoods.