Prescott City Council debates revised plans for Prescott Plaza Hotel construction

The Prescott City Council convened on July 8, 2025, to discuss a significant proposal that could reshape the historic Whiskey Row area. The council reviewed an appeal regarding the Prescott Plaza Hotel, a planned four-story boutique hotel with 47 rooms, located at 136-140 South Montezuma Street. This proposal has been a point of contention, having previously been denied by the Prescott Preservation Commission (PPC) and the council itself.

During the meeting, city officials and the applicant's representatives presented updates on the hotel design, which has undergone substantial revisions in response to earlier concerns. The new design features a reduced height, moving from five stories to four, and includes architectural changes aimed at better aligning with the historic character of the area. The applicant, Jim Grissett, emphasized the potential benefits of the hotel, including boosting local tourism and revitalizing the downtown area.

Council members expressed a mix of support and skepticism regarding the proposal. Some highlighted the importance of preserving the historical integrity of Whiskey Row, while others pointed out the need to balance property rights with community interests. The council discussed the legal implications of the Arizona Permit Freedom Act, which mandates that municipalities act on permit applications within a specified timeframe, raising questions about the council's options moving forward.

Public comments reflected a wide range of opinions. Supporters of the hotel argued it would enhance the local economy, while opponents raised concerns about its impact on the historic landscape and the potential for increased traffic and parking issues. Many community members called for a more thorough analysis from the historic preservation office before making a final decision.

In light of the discussions, the council decided to postpone action on the proposal to allow for further review and analysis of the updated design. This decision aims to ensure that all aspects of the project are carefully considered, balancing the need for development with the preservation of Prescott's unique historical character. The next steps will involve gathering more detailed feedback from the preservation commission and community stakeholders before a final vote is taken.