Hilo Council hears opposition to Bill 51 targeting feral cat feeding

The Hawaii County Policy Committee on Health, Safety, and Well-being convened on July 8, 2025, to discuss Bill 51, which addresses the feeding and management of free-roaming cats. The meeting featured multiple testimonies from community members, highlighting the complexities surrounding the proposed legislation.

The first speaker raised concerns about the implications of feeding feral cats, noting that while feeding can aid in trapping and neutering efforts, it also poses risks to wildlife and public health. The speaker emphasized the need for community education on the impacts of feeding animals and suggested that the bill should include exceptions for approved trap-neuter-release (TNR) programs.

William Brown, a local cat feeder and TNR advocate, testified against Bill 51, arguing that feeding is essential for managing cat populations effectively. He pointed out that many cats in his area are abandoned pets, and without feeding, the situation could worsen. Brown urged the committee to focus on enforcing abandonment laws and improving access to spay and neuter services rather than penalizing those who care for the animals.

Kristin Greenland, president of the Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, echoed these sentiments, stating that most cats on county property are abandoned pets. She criticized the lack of enforcement of existing abandonment laws and argued that Bill 51 conflicts with animal cruelty laws. Greenland called for a multifaceted approach that includes support for TNR programs and funding for spay-neuter services.

Craig Moody also opposed the bill, highlighting that it would push caregivers underground, creating unsafe conditions for both cats and people. He argued that the bill punishes compassion while failing to hold accountable those who abandon or abuse animals. Moody urged the committee to support proven TNR programs instead.

Greg Baker, a long-time resident and cat management advocate, shared a personal story about the importance of caring for community cats. He emphasized the need for structured and humane solutions to manage cat populations effectively.

The testimonies collectively underscored the community's commitment to addressing the cat overpopulation issue through compassionate and scientifically supported methods. The committee will need to consider these perspectives as they deliberate on the future of Bill 51 and its potential impact on both animal welfare and public health in Hawaii County.