Naperville Planning Commission reviews pool construction impact and neighbor runoff concerns

Concerns over stormwater runoff took center stage at the Village of Westmont Planning and Zoning Commission meeting on July 10, 2025, as residents voiced their apprehensions regarding a proposed in-ground pool at a neighboring property. The discussions highlighted the potential impact of increased lot coverage on existing water drainage issues in the area.

John Chorney, a resident directly affected by the proposal, expressed his worries about the current water runoff problems in his yard, which he described as a "wet spot" that has made it difficult to maintain his lawn. Chorney emphasized that while he has no objections to his neighbors enjoying a pool, he fears that the additional hardscape required for the pool could exacerbate existing drainage issues. "There's nowhere else for any of this water necessarily to percolate or to go," he stated, urging the commission to consider the implications of increased lot coverage.

The commission heard from staff and engineers who reported that the proposed pool would have a "minimal impact" on stormwater runoff. However, they acknowledged that the situation is complex and intertwined with existing engineering challenges in the area. The consulting engineer suggested options for mitigating runoff, including the installation of a dry well or reducing lot coverage by replacing some hard surfaces with permeable materials. Despite these recommendations, staff did not mandate any changes, leaving the decision to the commission.

Commissioners discussed the importance of addressing the neighbors' concerns while balancing the property owner's desire to build the pool. Some members suggested that if the pool were ever filled in or removed, the variance allowing increased lot coverage should also be revoked to prevent future complications.

As the meeting concluded, the commission moved toward a decision on the variance request, with a focus on ensuring that any approval would include measures to mitigate potential runoff issues. The outcome of this discussion will be crucial for both the property owner and the surrounding residents, as they navigate the challenges of water management in their community.