Committee advocates for steel over aluminum in storefront frame design

A significant discussion unfolded at the Historic Resources Board meeting on July 10, 2025, regarding the materials to be used in the storefront frame system for a local project. The debate centered on whether to use steel or aluminum, with board members emphasizing the aesthetic implications of each choice.

One board member pointed out a discrepancy between the project notes, which mentioned "painted steel or aluminum," and the presentation that specified only "steel." This raised questions about the final decision on materials. The member expressed a clear preference for steel, citing its superior sight lines and minimal button pattern, which are crucial for maintaining the building's historical integrity.

While acknowledging that some aluminum systems could also provide an appealing sight line, the board member reiterated the desire to stick with steel to align with existing structures. The discussion highlighted the importance of material choice in preserving the aesthetic character of the area, with a consensus leaning towards steel as the preferred option.

As the project moves forward, the board will continue to evaluate the material options, ensuring that the final decision reflects both historical significance and modern design standards.