J Street's local cochair critiques definitions of antisemitism in training sessions

A local Jewish leader raised critical concerns about the definition of antisemitism during the Human Relations Commission meeting on July 10, 2025, in Palo Alto. Speaking as the co-chair of the J Street Silicon Valley chapter, the speaker emphasized the need for careful consideration of how antisemitism is defined in upcoming training sessions.

The speaker expressed apprehension about the training provided by Project Shema, suggesting that its definition of antisemitism may extend beyond what many liberal Jews find acceptable. They highlighted the troubling trend of using accusations of antisemitism as a political weapon, particularly by some right-wing groups and individuals, which they believe detracts from addressing real threats like rising hate crimes and white nationalist rhetoric.

"Conflating anti-Zionism with criticism of Israel is not appropriate," the speaker stated, asserting that political criticism of any nation, including Israel, should not be labeled as antisemitism. They shared their own experiences of protesting against Israeli policies, underscoring that such actions are rooted in political beliefs rather than hatred.

The speaker concluded by urging the commission to adopt a nuanced understanding of antisemitism, warning against overly broad definitions that could stifle legitimate discourse. This discussion reflects ongoing tensions in the community regarding the intersection of political criticism and antisemitism, highlighting the need for thoughtful dialogue on these complex issues.